Clio vs MyCase: Which Is Better for Small Firms?
TLDR
For small law firms, MyCase is cheaper and easier to learn than Clio, but its invoicing is inflexible and document drafting is poor. Clio has deeper features but fragments them across four products and costs significantly more at higher tiers. Neither is purpose-built for firms with 1-20 attorneys — CaelusLaw offers a single product with IOLTA included starting at $20/user/month.
| Feature | Clio | MyCase | CaelusLaw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost (small team) | $39-149/user/mo | $39-99/user/mo | From $20/user/mo |
| Setup fee | Varies | Varies | $0 |
| Contract | Monthly available | Monthly available | Month-to-month |
| IOLTA trust accounting | Add-on or higher tier | Add-on or higher tier | Included |
Clio vs MyCase at a Glance
Clio and MyCase sit at different points on the complexity-versus-simplicity spectrum. Clio is the category leader with a $5 billion valuation and four separate products. MyCase is a more focused tool that solo and small firm attorneys adopt for its straightforward interface and lower price.
Whether you’re searching “Clio vs MyCase” or “MyCase vs Clio,” you’re asking the same question: which of these two tools is the right fit for a small firm? The answer depends on what you value most — feature depth or simplicity.
For firms with 1-20 attorneys, the trade-off is between Clio’s feature depth (at higher cost and complexity) and MyCase’s simplicity (with real limitations in invoicing and document drafting).
Pricing Comparison
As of March 2026:
Clio: EasyStart $39-49/user/month, Essentials $69-99/user/month, Complete $129-149/user/month. Clio Grow (CRM) is a separate subscription. Annual billing saves roughly 20%.
MyCase: Basic $39/user/month, Pro $79/user/month, Advanced $99/user/month. Annual billing discounts available.
For a 5-attorney firm on mid-tier plans: Clio Essentials costs $345-495/month. MyCase Pro costs $395/month. MyCase is consistently cheaper, with the gap widening at higher tiers ($495-745/month for Clio Complete vs $495/month for MyCase Advanced).
Key Differences
Invoicing: Clio offers more invoicing customization but users cite inconsistent reporting and “inconsistent terminology throughout the software.” MyCase’s invoicing is simpler but lacks the flexibility that contingency-fee firms and multi-case clients require. Users describe its customization options as inadequate.
Document drafting: Clio Draft is a separate product with real document automation capabilities. MyCase’s built-in document drafting is described by users as “horrible.” Firms that rely on document assembly will find MyCase insufficient.
Client management: MyCase handles single-matter clients well, but firms with clients who have multiple concurrent cases report organizational problems. Clio handles multi-matter clients more cleanly.
Reporting: Both draw criticism. Clio’s reports have “inconsistent filter options across reports.” MyCase’s reports are described as “confusing and hard to follow.”
Integrations: Clio has a larger third-party ecosystem. MyCase integrates with the essentials but offers fewer options overall.
Where CaelusLaw Fits
Clio is moving upmarket. MyCase is adequate for simple practices but hits walls on invoicing and document automation. Both are general-purpose tools serving firms of all sizes.
CaelusLaw is built for firms with 1-20 attorneys. IOLTA trust accounting is included at every tier, starting with Essentials ($20/user/month), not gated behind enterprise pricing. One product, not four. If your firm needs more than MyCase offers but less complexity than Clio demands, CaelusLaw is worth evaluating.
| Feature | Clio | MyCase | CaelusLaw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $39/user/mo (EasyStart) | $39/user/mo (Basic) | $20/user/mo (Essentials, IOLTA included) |
| Mid-tier price | $69-99/user/mo (Essentials) | $79/user/mo (Pro) | $39/user/mo (Complete) |
| Trust accounting | Essentials tier+ | Pro tier only | Included at every tier |
| Client portal | Clio Grow (separate) | Included | Included |
| CRM / intake | Clio Grow (separate, $49+/user) | Basic | Included |
| Document automation | Clio Draft (separate) | Limited (poor reviews) | Planned |
| Contract required | No (monthly available) | No (monthly available) | No |
PROS & CONS
Clio
Pros
- 600+ third-party integrations via Clio marketplace
- Document automation via Clio Draft add-on
- Stronger reporting and analytics at higher tiers
Cons
- Client portal requires Clio Grow as a separate subscription
- More complex setup and steeper learning curve
- Base Manage plan lacks trust accounting
PROS & CONS
MyCase
Pros
- Polished client portal included in base plan
- Easier onboarding — most firms report going live faster
- Competitive payment processing rates
Cons
- Fewer third-party integrations than Clio
- Advanced billing features require higher plan
- Trust accounting not in base plan
Is MyCase or Clio better for a small firm?
MyCase is generally easier to onboard and less expensive at lower tiers ($39-99/user/month). Clio has more integrations and document automation. For firms under 10 attorneys without complex integration needs, MyCase is often a better fit — though both lack the pricing transparency of CaelusLaw.
Does MyCase have better client communication than Clio?
Yes. MyCase's client portal is widely regarded as more polished and easier for clients to use. Clio's client-facing tools (via Clio Grow) require a separate subscription.
Which is cheaper — Clio or MyCase for a 5-attorney firm?
MyCase is cheaper at every comparable tier. Five attorneys on MyCase Pro costs $395/month. Five attorneys on Clio Essentials costs $345-495/month for Manage only, plus $245+ for Clio Grow if you need a client portal. MyCase includes the client portal in all plans.
Which has better trust accounting — Clio or MyCase?
Neither is purpose-built for trust accounting. Both require at least a mid-tier plan to access IOLTA features. Clio's trust accounting is more mature and audited. MyCase's trust accounting at the Pro tier handles basic IOLTA deposits and disbursements but users report complications with multi-matter client trust tracking.
Source: Clio pricing page (March 2026)
Source: MyCase pricing page (March 2026)
Verdict
MyCase wins on price and simplicity. Clio wins on features and integrations. Both have significant weaknesses for small firms — Clio's product fragmentation and MyCase's invoicing limitations. CaelusLaw ($20-39/user/month) addresses both gaps with a single product that includes IOLTA trust accounting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Clio or MyCase cheaper for a small law firm?
Which is easier to use — Clio or MyCase?
Does MyCase or Clio have better invoicing?
Can I switch from MyCase to Clio?
Ready to simplify your practice?
Reserve Your SpotNo credit card required. No annual contract.
Related Comparisons
Best Clio Alternative for Small Law Firms
Looking for a Clio alternative? CaelusLaw is built for 1-20 attorney firms — one product instead of four, IOLTA trust accounting included, starting at $20/user/mo.
Best MyCase Alternative for Small Law Firms
Looking for a MyCase alternative? CaelusLaw offers better invoicing, multi-case handling, and IOLTA trust accounting included — starting at $20/user/mo.
MyCase Pricing Breakdown (2026): What It Really Costs
What does MyCase actually cost for a small law firm? We break down per-user pricing, invoicing limitations, and hidden costs across all tiers.
How to Choose Legal Practice Management Software for Your Small Firm
A step-by-step guide for small law firm partners evaluating practice management software. Covers must-have features, IOLTA compliance, pricing models, and migration planning.
How to Manage a Small Law Firm: Systems, Software, and Operations
A practical guide to managing a solo or small law firm — covering matter management, billable time tracking, trust accounting, court deadline systems, and client intake. Written for 1-20 attorney practices.